Here is my out of control tank...
and after I used Joe's Juice and got some peppermints...
I agree that it is hit or miss with the peppermints but I think they are the easiest and cheapest way to eliminate aiptasia. Just kill some of the larger ones with Joe's Juice and the peppermints get the rest.
(sorry for lagging your connections with these big pictures but sometimes you don't feel like writing the thousand words that the picture is worth.)