Aqua C Pro Urchin skimmer

[Fischer's Angel]

Would the Aqua C Pro Urchin skimmer be my best choice for an in-sump skimmer for a 55 gallon tank with moderate to heavy load? If not,what would be your choice for an in-sump skimmer for a 55 gallon?

[Percula9]

I would recommend a Euroreef or ASM skimmer. The Aqua C is a Remora and a lot of people on this forum don't think there good skimmers.

[sjm817]

The Urchin is among the worst in sump skimmers you could choose. There are many better choices.

[Fischer's Angel]

O.K. so sjm817 which in sump skimmer would you recommend for 55 gallons?

Thanks for the fast reply,by the way!

[sjm817]

A Euro-Reef RS-80 would be a good one.

[TK3]

I have a Deltec MCE600 on my tank and have been quite happy.

[MikeyNYC]

Aqua C Urchin Pro is a really good skimmer, don't let the options of few make your decision. Everyone's application is different, and what is good for one person may not be good for another. The skimmer has been popular in the market for a long time because of it's decent price and it's compact size. If have decent amount of room that you can dedicate to the skimmer, then maybe the skimmer isn't the best choice, it's really good choice for those with limited space either in sump or external (remora). I wish you luck with your choice, don't feel compelled to spend your life saving on a fish tank,

[sjm817]

Marine Depot prices
Aqua C Urchin Pro with Mag 3 $227
ER RS 80 $238

For an extra $11, you get a far superior skimmer.

You can get an Octopus NW-150 which is also a far better skimmer for $170