Regarding a closed thread

[SciGuy2]

John,

I stumbled upon this thread that you closed.

http://archive.reefcentral.com/vbulletin/showthread.php?threadid=49361&goto=newpost

I agree that several of the points made in the posts were cached in innuendo. However, I believe that several valid questions were being raised. I feel that your comments were sufficient and the thread should not have been closed.

By closing the thread we have been denied the most obvious platform wherein we could have expected a reply from IceCap short of watching their Vendor Forum.

BTW, I'm a happy IceCap customer, but I would have liked to have seen the thread play out in a civil manor.

Thank you,
-Sci

[JohnL]

I'm pretty sure a new thread ASKING Andy for information and not accusing him of deception would be replied to by Andy in a very informative manner. How about giving that a try?

[SciGuy2]

Agreed. That would be a much better approach. People are getting way too tough on those that supply our hobby.

Thanks,
-Sci

[Agu]

Sci,

Thanks for understanding :) .

For my opinion on the issue, see my response to the post by commie.

Agu